« Milledge Shines, But Mets Still Fall | Main | Soler Dominant as Mets Draw First Blood in LA »

Milledge -- Unkind to Animals and Small Children?

Mike SteffanosMonday, June 5, 2006
By Mike Steffanos

Lastings Milledge came up to the Mets as an emergency replacement for Xavier Nady last Tuesday. Hard to believe it's been less than a week, because there has been a big enough sh*tstorm over this kid to last a season. Everything is fair game with him, his talent, his potential, his past, and his character -- as if some kid who has walked this planet for a scant 21 years and plays a kid's game is somehow worthy of all the ink and hot air spilled on him, including what has been written in this space.

I confess up front that all I know about Lasting Milledge is what I read and what little I've seen. I do not qualify as a professional talent evaluator, and I have not spent the time around him that some in the press have. Having seen him in action now, I have been able to witness flashes of the talent that many gush about and the "flash" that turns so many off. As with any other top athlete, you simply cannot separate the talent from the man himself. It all goes together to make Lastings what he is -- and frankly, unlike some out there who feel they have seen enough to pass judgment, I'm still not sure what this kid is, either as a person or a ballplayer.

In his first few days in the major leagues, Milledge has certainly become a lightening rod for controversy. It seems as if everyone is willing to weigh in with an opinion on this kid, whether they really have a clue about him or not. Case in point, take this comment by a pious, self-righteous Yankee blogger, who quoted extensively from Mike McGann's unflattering portrait of Milledge:

While some might say that it's wrong to point at something bad to make something else look good, I still have to say this: What a pleasure it is to watch young Melky Cabrera go about his business while he's succeeding at the Major League level.

The Mets can have Milledge. I'd rather have Melky without question.

I've always said the Yankees are all about character over talent: Gary Sheffield, Jason Giambi, Roger Clemens ... the list goes on and on. Don't worry, Steve, you can rest assured that the Mets will not trade Milledge for the great Melky Cabrera, so you can enjoy having his fourth outfielder skills in the Bronx for the foreseeable future. Anyhow, reading this guy's pathetic desire to latch onto something negative about the Mets' big prospect shines a light on how silly this whole thing is. Maybe we all should stop pretending that we know something about Milledge, whether we hope to see him fall on his face like our buddy Steve, or succeed like most of us Mets fans.

What I'm not seeing at this point is any evidence that Milledge is any kind of bad kid -- other than being a little full of himself and his own talent and lacking the proper behavioral filters to hide that from the rest of the world. He has an ego, and obviously enjoys the attention the fans. I can live with that. Did he high-five fans at an inappropriate time in yesterday's game? Sure he did. Is this the same as Vince Coleman throwing fireworks at fans? Don't think so. I like Metstradamus' take on the "incident":

... In an era where professional sports fans get screwed over left and right, Lastings Milledge's actions today probably won the sport of baseball a handful of fans for life. I applaud a player that makes the fans feel like a part of the game and acknowledges their presence rather than put on earplugs to drown them out. I find no problem with that, and players that do have a problem with it should lighten up a hair. And dare I say because I don't know for sure, but I'd be willing to bet money that a lot of the same players that would condemn Lastings' act are the same ones that are rushing to the defense of one Barry Bonds...the same Barry Bonds that probably wouldn't bother to spit on a fan if he was on fire. High fiving fans vs. refusing autographs. Which is worse?

If what happens yesterday turns out to be the biggest transgression Lastings Milledge is ever guilty of, I think I and most other Mets fans can live with it. One thing that has been obvious to me in watching Milledge play and in what I've read about him is that the kid loves baseball. You can't say that about everyone that plays the game -- as any Mets fan that suffered through the Kevin McReynolds years knows all too well. I tend to doubt that Milledge's personality is going to endear him to the players, coaches and fans of the other teams. Maybe he gets a little too much of that "Big Time" attitude and the press doesn't warm to him. But if he goes about his life and doesn't cause hurt to people, cuddly animals or the environment, if he plays solid baseball and gets along with his teammates, I'm not thinking that I'll give a sh*t about the rest.

A heads-up on the next week
The games tonight, Tuesday and Wednesday night against the Dodgers all go off at 10:10 PM our time. The Thursday, Friday and Saturday night games against Arizona all start at 9:40 PM. In April, when the Mets went to San Diego and San Francisco, I watched all of those late games and blogged afterwards. It was my own stubborn fault, but I went into a downturn with my illness from pushing myself so hard that I still haven't bounced all the way back from. Perhaps it also has something to do with 1 out of 5 Mets games so far going extra innings.

Anyway, I'm going to back off a little this week for my own good. I really haven't been feeling too good lately as it is. I probably won't watch every single game, nor blog late at night. If I do watch a game and blog after it, I may just do a short post covering highlights. I'm not quite sure how I'll handle this week, and plan to play it day by day. I value those of you that read this site day after day, and am sorry if things are a little spotty for a while.

More Mets Stories:
SportsSpyder Mets
Pro Sports Daily Mets

Comments (8)

Good points about Milledge. From seeing him, he reminded me of Ernie Banks -- not for talent (time will tell with that), but with the fun he seemed to be having. One player who enjoys the game as much as Milledge does is worth his weight in solid gold fungo bats.


Hi Mike- I know people won't agree with me here, but Idon't see the star power in Milledge that I saw with Wright and Reyes-and of course after I said that publically on sportstalkcleveland.com when asked about it he goes three for four and makes and outstanding catch in the outfield on Sunday-he may just need more seasoning down in the minors, but he looks very over matched at the plate when faces anyone who can throw more than a fast ball, and he has to learn to listen to his thrid base coach and not look for the ball once it's caught-the coach is there so you don't have to think- he says go and you run home-luckily due to his speed and the kind of slide he made they won that second game on Saturday.

I think he will be a good solid outfielder who can hit for a decent average, but I don't see a breakout superstar here-at least not yet.

Shari. Check out these stats:
496 ABs | .266 AVG | 11 HR | 114 Ks
466 ABs | .270 AVG | 15 HR | 98 Ks

Not very good. It's what David Wright hit in A-Ball in 2002 and 2003 -- the 2 years before he got called up. He was considered somewhat of a failed prospect, but he just wasn't ready. In 2004 he tore it up in AA, AAA and then with the Mets.

It's hard to guess with prospects, and I'm no expert. I don't think the Mets believe Milledge is ready yet, and they wouldn't have brought him up if Nady didn't go down. I don't think he'll be the kind of player Wright has turned out to be, but I believe he'll be a real good player.

I wasn't writing about how good I think he will be, though. I was reacting to all the stuff written about him as a person.

Mike-agree with your points about Milledge. I don't know what kind of player or person he is going to be, but any pro athlete that actually touches a lowly fan is ok with me!

Especially when they touch fans without throwing punches at them...

Mike I have to say that seeing him give the high fives was pretty cool. Remember how the Cubs fans loved Sosa just because he would sprint out to them and throw them kisses and carry little flags. Well why the hell cant this young guy get the fans on his side by throwing a bunch of high ones? Any kid who got one from Milledge would be a life long Mets fan and probably demand to go out and sit where he can high 5 milledge. Screw the front office, do it kid and we will be behind you.

He looked rough at times I agree. Now he has a taste of the big leagues though and he hasn't failed. Now he has to go back to AAA and work on his pitch recognition and come back in September and show who he really is.

Well, in fairness to the Mets, they're just worried about the kid becoming a target for other teams in the league. I've heard that, other than that, Randolph and the other players got a kick out of it.

It's impossible to tell at this point if he will be great, but I think he'll at least be pretty good. We've been spoiled with Wright, but if your system can produce solid major-league starting players you're doing well. And this kid has a chance to be real, real good.

About Mike's Mets

Please support Mike's Mets:

Disclaimer: Mike's Mets is an independent, unofficial fan site, and is not affiliated in any way with the New York Mets or Major League Baseball.

Other Links

General Baseball Links
Internet Radio Shows
Video Blogs
Other Team Links
Other Sports Links
Non-Sports Links
Video Direct

Looking for great deals on MLB Baseball Tickets? Visit JustgreatTickets.com for Cubs Tickets, NY Mets Tickets and a huge selection of Red Sox Tickets, Yankees Tickets and plenty of great concert Tickets for Dave Matthews Band Tickets and Buffett Tickets

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 4.1