« It Could Have Been Worse, I Guess | Main | Time to Bring It »

The Team to Beat

Mike SteffanosMonday, July 21, 2008
By Mike Steffanos

With the Phillies rolling into town tomorrow for a three-game series, the question arises as to which team is the favorite to capture the NL East with 63 games to go.

NJ.com links to a Jayson Stark chat on ESPN where Stark comes to the following conclusion:

The fashionable choice would be to pick the Mets, but I'm not going to let the last couple of weeks talk me into that. If I line up the Mets and Phillies, I'm hard-pressed to find an area in which I think the Mets are substantially better. The Phillies have outscored them, outpitched them and outfielded them. And you can look that up. I'd take the Phillies' lineup and bullpen over the Mets' lineup and 'pen. And while the Mets may have better starting pitching, the Blanton trade and those never-ending Pedro Martinez questions have narrowed that margin considerably. The Phillies haven't played well for a month now. But the Mets have enough age, health and chemistry issues that I'm still picking the Phillies to win the East. Disagree? Go right ahead. That's what we're here for.

Glad to hear the Mets have become the "fashionable choice" again, since it seems to me it's still fashionable to bash them (and rightfully so) for their inconsistent and indifferent play over most of the past year. As a commenter to NJ.com's post points out, Stark is from Philadelphia and hardly an unbiased pundit in this matter.

As much as I'd like to completely bash Stark on this one, I think the jury is still out on this race. I will agree with him that the Phillies have the superior lineup, and their bullpen has outperformed their Mets counterparts rather substantially. I do think the Mets have a big advantage in starting pitching if John Maine can remove his head from his butt and Pedro keeps it together, but no one will accuse this Mets starting rotation of being the sort of dominant group that can carry a team long-term.

Frankly, the biggest question to me is whether the Mets can sustain the really sharp play they had pre-break. It wasn't really there in Cincy this past series, which is why the Mets were lucky to split. That was a huge disappointment to me and to other fans I've talked to.

The Mets proved last season that they're not the type of team that can overcome indifferent play by overwhelming opposing teams with talent. While both the Mets and Phillies have had their problems this season and the Mets have won all three series so far, I still think the nature of last season's collapse and 2008 first half struggles leave the Mets with something to prove against their opponents from down the turnpike.

Moreover, I see the Marlins continue to overcome their own deficiencies with a determination and gameness that we only have seen from the Mets recently. Baseball is a game for those with long attention spans, and if the Mets can't bring their A game most of the time they will not get it done over the last two months of the season.

We've heard some of the Mets players, including David Wright, insist that the Mets were a "great team" that simply wasn't playing to their capabilities. I like David, but he's wrong. This is a good team that can be a solid contender if they do the little things right. Doing those little things right is what earned them a 10-game win streak and a new chance at making the last season at Shea worthwhile. It was gone for most of this weekend, and it showed. The Mets can't afford to believe they can turn it on and off at will.

Look, I know some fans get mad when they read something like what Stark had to say, but I could honestly care less. Last season I read one pundit after another who thought that the Mets would get it together and hold on to win the division. You don't win or lose based on the consensus of pundits.

If the Mets can get a healthy Ryan Church back they probably have enough offense to compete. The bullpen had some hiccups in Cincy, but they really have been much better in July than earlier in the year. If Wagner can hold it together they're good enough to win with. Same with the starters, especially if Maine figures it out.

Bottom line, in an NL eastern division that has no great teams, if the Mets take care of their own business they can win it. After yesterday's game, Jerry Manuel acknowledged that the Mets had won, but had not played winning baseball. He went on to say that they couldn't afford not to play winning baseball against the Phillies and Marlins if they hoped to win this division. I think that holds true for whoever they face in the final ten weeks of the season.

Marlon Anderson
Marlon Anderson looked really bad on that Ken Griffey fly ball he lost in the sun. Defense has never been his forte, but he usually managed to hold his own when he's in there.

A brutal April and May have pretty much ensured that a part-timer like Marlon won't put up good offensive numbers for the season. He also has a lingering leg injury that I'm told is similar to what Scott Schoeneweis dealt with last season. Remember all of the huge late inning hits he had last year that were squandered when the bullpen gave it up? In only 69 AB with New York last season Anderson drove in an astonishing 25 RBI while hitting .319/.355/.551. Longer memories, please, people.

Pinch hitting is one of the toughest jobs in sports, and Anderson is one of the best in the game, despite this year's struggles. He's also tried to be a leader of this team, which Marty Noble documents in this story.

I like Marlon Anderson, and I still think he can play a positive role in this season if he gets hot. Moreover, he's signed through next season, so those who think he should be released are not being realistic. It's not that easy to find productive bench guys, anyway.

About Mike: I was the original writer on this web site, actually its only writer for the first 15 months of existence. Although I am grateful for the excellent contributions of my fellow writers here, I have no plans of stepping back into strictly an editorial role. I started this thing in the first place because I love to write and I love the Mets, and blogging here keeps me somewhat sane. If you haven't had enough already, more bio info can be found here.

Support Mike's Mets by shopping at our Amazon Store

Comments (6)

About Anderson, this year's struggles is no joke.

I no longer like Marlon Anderson, and I now think he can't do it any more.

But let me put it another way, he just does not look like he cares any more. He does not seem to play with aggression to win. it's like he is just waiting out his contract, then he can get a beach house and not be hassled any more by coming to the park.

As for Marlon Anderson, I really like him overall, it's just that A) he looks old out there B) has no range defensively and C)doesn't belong on a team trying to make the postseason and needs every position available.

The Mets should send him to AAA if they want him for next year, and let someone else make plays that would have given the Mets a 5-2 win last night.


Marlon is just in a funk, and granted his production is hardly meriting a roster spot. However he is a good clubhouse guy and leader. If he can get it going, he will be a valuable pinch hitter. I don't know if DFA'ing him, realeasing, or sending him down is the "right" thing to do at this time. Will it disrupt the chemistry? Will his leadership be missed? Those are things to ponder. I do believe the Mets can get a more productive bat whether within the organization ( J-Rod, Super Val) or outside. I would prefer the Mets to seek out a cheap righthanded bat to platoon in the outfield and pick up a reliever or two. I don't know why but I am stuck on Gomes(TB), and Blake(Clev)for the outfield and Fuentes(Col) who will cost, and possibly Bradford (Balt) a salary dump and maybe Street(Oak)who might not be that expensive. All in all Omar needs to make a tweak here and there to balance out this club.

I disagree somewhat with your thought that the fire, intensity or whatever has left the Mets, as evidenced by the Cincinnati series.

Personally, I expected the Mets to lose after the first victory in Cincy. It was an emotionally draining game; it's only human for there to be something of a letdown. And Maine might have escaped anyhow, if that Baltimore Chop to Wright has bounced a little differently.

The Perez game, I'll grant you, was a disappointment. But I liked how the Mets persevered in the final game, as ugly as it was. The team might not fare well against Philadelphia, the Phils are a good team, but I fully expect the Mets to show up ready to play.

Why do I get the feeling that Wagner and some are setting excuses for a down fall, when they can't deliver what they were hired to do. Get us into the playoffs.L ast year it was his back when we needed him most, this year it's his shoulder? Our "ace" is not really delivering also, when we need a solid outing? I feel they are shying away from a must win and possible choke. So they start making excuses already, just in case. Hope I'm wrong.

fredsaid - if he didn't care, why would he have been the one to try to inspire the team per Noble's story that I linked to?
Jason - It wouldn't shock me at all if he got hot down the stretch and really helped them. There aren't a lot of guys who are dependable pinch hitters like he is. On the other hand, he shouldn't be playing a lot of innings in the OF. If they get Church back, he wouldn't anyway. Endy and Tatis would get the majority of time out there, and Easley some too once Castillo returns.
L.J. - As with what I said above, if he gets hot like he did last year I doubt there would be a more productive bench bat available.
dd - They battled, that's for sure, but they didn't always play smart. The quality of some of the ABs was lacking in the Fri and Sat games. They need to play hard and smart down the stretch. I don't that they were playing their A game against the Reds, and that bothered me.
Al - I don't know that Wagner is making excuses so much as dealing with a lot of physical issues that tend to make him less effective as the season goes on. I hope you're wrong, too.

About Mike's Mets

Please support Mike's Mets:

Disclaimer: Mike's Mets is an independent, unofficial fan site, and is not affiliated in any way with the New York Mets or Major League Baseball.

Other Links

General Baseball Links
Internet Radio Shows
Video Blogs
Other Team Links
Other Sports Links
Non-Sports Links
Video Direct

Looking for great deals on MLB Baseball Tickets? Visit JustgreatTickets.com for Cubs Tickets, NY Mets Tickets and a huge selection of Red Sox Tickets, Yankees Tickets and plenty of great concert Tickets for Dave Matthews Band Tickets and Buffett Tickets

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 4.1