« Preliminary Thought on the Mets -- Position Players | Main | Thrown Out of Shea »

Preliminary Thought on the Mets -- The Bench

Mike SteffanosFriday, February 20, 2009
By Mike Steffanos

We'll finish up our initial thoughts on the 2009 Mets -- which was supposed to be a brief overview but somehow grew into War and Peace -- with a look at the bench today and conclude with a final summation tomorrow.

The consensus seems to be that the Mets are likely to carry 12 pitchers, which will leave room for 13 position players. Since the Mets seem committed to a platoon with Murphy and Tatis in LF, that would leave 4 other spots open.

One will almost certainly go to a catcher. Barring any late signings or injury, the only real candidate is Ramon Castro. When he's healthy, he's a legitimate offensive force for a catcher, and not a bad defensive player.

Castro, who will turn 33 next month, has never accumulated more than the 209 AB he totaled his first season with the Mets in '05. There are several starting catchers in MLB who have less talent than Castro, who was a first round pick in 1994. The only thing they have over him is the ability to stay on the field.

Castro will make $2.5 million this season in the second year of a two-year deal he signed. In his fifth year now as a Met, you sense that frustration is mounting with this talented player who seems very content to backup lesser talents and, as mentioned, cannot stay healthy. I don't think he's going anywhere this season, but it wouldn't shock me if the Mets elected to let him go this winter.

The club carried 3 catchers at times last year, but I don't see that happening this year. Look for Castro to catch a game or two a week until he goes down with some leg injury this summer. Robinson Cancel will be counting the days in Buffalo waiting for that to happen.

With Castro and the non-playing half of the left field platoon occupying the first two slots on the bench, a third would have to go to a backup infielder who can play both 2B and SS. Considering the $2 million contract he was handed, that would undoubtedly be Alex Cora.

The good about Cora is that he is a much better shortstop than anyone the Mets had on the roster last year, so perhaps Reyes might get a day off here and there.

The bad is that he is a lifetime .245/.313/.348 hitter and yet another lefty on a team that is top-heavy with them.

By all accounts, Cora is a good clubhouse guy and a smart ballplayer. I can't help think that $2 million could have paid for a lot more offense, but that's water under the bridge at this point.

With two roster spots left, the primary candidates are Marlon Anderson, Nick Evans, Angel Pagan, Jeremy Reed, Cory Sullivan and non roster invitees Ramon Martinez, Jose Valentin, Bobby Kielty and Rob Mackowiak. Let's take a brief look at them:

Marlon Anderson has value because he's a terrific pinch hitter. He was awful last year, but he was never healthy. In two stints with the Mets he's had a ton of big hits, and seems to love being up at a big moment. Because of that, if he is truly healthy, he's the guy I like most of this bunch. The biggest negative is that he is a LH hitter.

Nick Evans was good in spurts last season when he actually beat Daniel Murphy to the bigs. He's a RH bat with some power who could play both 1B and OF. That alone gives him his best chance of making the team. Unlike fellow rook Murphy, though, Evans does not work an at bat well. He'll need to learn to be more selective to have a good shot of sticking.

Pagan was great last year, but was essentially done for the season in mid-May, so he'll have to impress all over again. He's a very good defensive OF with a little bit of pop, and it also helps that he's a switch hitter. The bad is that he is much better hitting from the left side and doesn't have enough power to justify a lot of ABs as a corner OF.

Jeremy Reed came over in the Putz deal. Not that long ago he was a top prospect, but now he's a young veteran (28 in June) who has failed to live up to his minor league numbers (.321/.388/.476) in the majors (.257/.314/.365). He's reportedly a good defender, but he's another lefty. Pagan would be more versatile, Reed has with more upside, but the clock is ticking.

Cory Sullivan is a fine defensive OF, but also a LH hitter with little power. (It's as if that's a commodity the Mets tried to corner the market on this winter.) He's older than Pagan and Reed and doesn't walk enough. The swami foresees a summer in Buffalo in this man's future.

Martinez was great in a short stint at the end of last year. He's also a RH hitter who can play all the infield positions and some OF. He's 36 years old with his best days behind him, but has a lot of experience as a pinch hitter. That, the RH bat and the versatility gives him some small chance of grabbing a spot.

Jose Valentin admits that he just wanted to give it one more shot as a player before going on to coaching. I don't think he'll make it as a player, but I would allow him to manage in my farm system any day. I have a feeling we might see him in the majors again someday in that capacity.

Kielty is interesting as the rare switch-hitter who is stronger from the right side, which is obviously a need on this team. He hasn't had a major league home run since 2006, though, and is more likely to be flanking Cory Sullivan in Buffalo rather than Carlos Beltran in Queens.

Rob Mackowiak is another of those lefty OFs. There was a time when he wasn't a terrible offensive player, but the last two seasons he hit .196 for the Padres and .132 for the Nats after enjoying a couple of solid years with the White Sox.

My best guess -- which you could probably equal with a Ouija board -- is that Marlon Anderson and Angel Pagan grab the other two bench spots along with Castro, Cora and whichever half of the LF platoon doesn't start. I wouldn't bet the farm on my guess, though. I wouldn't be totally surprised if any of the above names grabbed the last 2 spots. I think the battle for those jobs will be the most wide-open in camp.

Preliminary Thoughts on the 2009 Mets:
Part 1 -- Pitchers
Part 2 -- Position Players
Part 3 -- The Bench (This Article)

About Mike: I was the original writer on this web site, actually its only writer for the first 15 months of existence. Although I am grateful for the excellent contributions of my fellow writers here, I have no plans of stepping back into strictly an editorial role. I started this thing in the first place because I love to write and I love the Mets, and blogging here keeps me somewhat sane. If you haven't had enough already, more bio info can be found here.

Support Mike's Mets by shopping at our Amazon Store

Comments (3)

An interesting grab bag of players, no?

Just because he once looked like something special I am interested in seeing if Kielty has anything to show us. Ditto, more or less, for Reed, though Kielty was briefly impressive on a major league level (he finished 4th for the Rookie of the Year award in 2002). Pagan I see as sort of a lower-case Endy Chavez, the same sort of player only not as good at anything (he's a switch hitter but I'm not convinced it make a difference in his case).

Nick Evans could probably benefit from some fine tuning in the minors; I'm guessing his ceiling is of a fringe regular or fourth non-centerfield outfielder.

I like Anderson; how could a Mets fan not like him? I only hope he doesn't get awarded a spot on past performances.

Conspicuously missing are the names of rookies who could fight their way onto the roster, for shame.

By the way: if you want to name an award that tells you very little about future performance, check out the votings for Rookie of the Year over the years. Usually the winner will go on to a good career, but....well, take a trip down memory lane with me. It's 2000, American League:

The voting:

1 Kaz Sasaki
2 Terrence Long
3 Mark Quinn
4 Bengie Molina
5 Kelly Wunsch
6 Steve Cox
7 Adam Kennedy
8 Mark Redman
9 Barry Zito

Sasaki was over 30 when he won, which is stupid; Quinn was a hitter but also a red ass, currently toiling in the minors I believe. Terry Long? Kelly Wunsch? Steve Cox? Ugh. Zito was a star, of course, apparently on the mend today, but that contract will never look good.

I would like to see Kielty make the team, I am always partial to switch hitters, they lengthen your lineup and unless they are absolutely pathetic from one side they rarely have to get pinch hit for. I think Nick Evans can be a force if he learns better plate discipline. Pagan if healthy will be great. The rest of the bunch is a mixed bag. What in the name of Guiseppe Franco is going on with the Mets not obtaining a power righty bat for the bench? I guess we will have to wait and see what happens between Spring Training and the WBC.

About Mike's Mets

Please support Mike's Mets:

Disclaimer: Mike's Mets is an independent, unofficial fan site, and is not affiliated in any way with the New York Mets or Major League Baseball.

Other Links

General Baseball Links
Internet Radio Shows
Video Blogs
Other Team Links
Other Sports Links
Non-Sports Links
Video Direct

Looking for great deals on MLB Baseball Tickets? Visit JustgreatTickets.com for Cubs Tickets, NY Mets Tickets and a huge selection of Red Sox Tickets, Yankees Tickets and plenty of great concert Tickets for Dave Matthews Band Tickets and Buffett Tickets

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 4.1