« Your Obligatory Brad Emaus Post | Main | Zen and the Art of Self-Delusion »

Fire Sale Blues

Mike SteffanosWednesday, April 20, 2011
By Mike Steffanos


Remember back a few winters ago when you were constantly reading that a trade that would bring Manny Ramirez to the Mets was inevitable? This year's "inevitable" seems to be a fire sale this summer in Flushing. Particularly with Jose Reyes, the question of a trade doesn't seem to be if, but just when.

While I certainly concede the possibility of a fire sale, I've been arguing against the conventional wisdom of inevitability since I returned to blogging here this spring. Without rehashing everything again, let's take a closer look at trading Reyes.

I start this by acknowledging the argument against signing Reyes long term. If I was the GM of this team I would be very leery of signing Jose to the 7-year, $100 million plus contract that's been speculated about. While he might very well remain healthy and productive into his mid-30s, if he were to suffer a Beltran-like injury it's hard to see where he could provide any value to compensate for a loss of speed and the ability to play shortstop.

Once you acknowledge the fact that keeping Reyes past this year is unlikely, then the balance sheet you must look at as a General Manager is to compare the value of keeping Reyes all year to the value of trading him.

The positives of keeping Reyes all season would be a club that is more interesting to watch in 2011, with higher attendance and television ratings than if you traded him. Also a plus would be the two high draft picks you would receive when he signs with someone else as a free agent.

For me as a GM to even contemplate trading Reyes, then, I need to receive more value in return than I am giving up. I need a return greater than simply the equivalent of the 2 high draft picks, which I should assume will net me a pair of high-ceiling prospects if I do my job correctly.

So I want either three high-ceiling prospects in return or, at the very least, a couple of guys who are close to major league ready plus something else to sweeten the deal and compensate me for giving up Reyes. I don't want a couple of guys who are years away, because I haven't gained anything in return for giving up having Jose Reyes for the rest of the summer. I need to go back to my club's fan base with something to show for this deal.

Now the other team is obviously getting more than just a rental of Jose Reyes in return -- they're also getting those two draft picks if they are unable or unwilling to keep Reyes. So the real question is whether a potential trade partner sees Reyes as the missing piece between them and a strong post-season run. Then they're willing to give up big prospects to roll the dice.

I know there are clubs that are badly in need of a shortstop, with possibilities including the Giants with an aging Miguel Tejada and Milwaukee with the light-hitting Yuniesky Betancourt, among others. Still, for these potential trade partners to agree to hand over the haul of prospects a Reyes deal would demand, they really have to see Jose as THE ANSWER. Do any of these clubs covet Jose badly enough to justify the hit on their farm system -- and if they do, do they match up with prospects the Mets want? It's possible, but it's certainly not inevitable.

If the Mets can't find a trade partner with that particular combination of need, want and the right chips to deal, it might wind up making more sense to keep Reyes around all season and then do your best to make the draft picks pay off.

Of course, it's fair to say that if the Mets continue this extreme suckage there is less reason to hold onto a Jose Reyes or anyone else. They won't be drawing fans in the park and no one will be watching the telecasts, anyway. But you still need to find the right deal.

As an informed fan, I am going to take a close look at any deal the Mets make this summer, and if I see something that smells like just a salary dump I am not going to be a happy camper. On the other hand, though, if Sandy Alderson can make a strong deal I will be all for it, even if the short-term result almost certainly makes the Mets even harder to watch in 2011.

If you are just finding this blog again and wondering why I was gone for so long and what the plan is going forward, read this.

About Mike: I was the original writer on this web site, actually its only writer for the first 15 months of existence. Although I am grateful for the excellent contributions of my fellow writers here, I have no plans of stepping back into strictly an editorial role. I started this thing in the first place because I love to write and I love the Mets, and blogging here keeps me somewhat sane. If you haven't had enough already, more bio info can be found here.


Comments (3)

hi welcome back your the only writer that does not bash the met. mike`up is so far up the yankees nose he make a living bashing mets. and putting down the mgr. well would someone lite a fire under wright/beltran/reyes/ sit them down for a few games what could happen we lose a couple of games guess what we already do

I would try and keep Reyes for a 3-4 year deal and move Wright.Between the beaning and playing in this ridiculous dimensioned ballpark, which completely takes away from davids strengths as a gap hitter, if i was Alderson i would look to move Wright.He appears to be a .270 to .280 hitter with 25-28 homer potential who will strikeout 160 plus times every year with a shaky throwing arm.That said at the end of his contract he will probably be looking for at least 5 years at close to 100 mill.Judging by his declining skills and increasing strikeouts, the mets would be crazy to pay him that kind of money.On the other hand, Reyes when healthy is one of the best players at his position in MLB.The Philles need a replacement for Polanco down the road.If i'm david wright i'd be dreaming of hitting in Citizens Bank Park for 4-5 years with a Phillies jersey on.Free Agency here i come.

Thanks for the comments, guys.

Fred -- It's not a bad idea maybe to take a David Wright who's been awful and at least sit him for a game.

Anonymous -- I don't think Reyes would sign for a 3-4 year deal, but if he did I'd be surprised if they didn't sign him. Wright is on a pretty reasonable contract and it would seem to me his value is actually quite low right now.

About Mike's Mets

Please support Mike's Mets:

Disclaimer: Mike's Mets is an independent, unofficial fan site, and is not affiliated in any way with the New York Mets or Major League Baseball.

Other Links

General Baseball Links
Internet Radio Shows
Video Blogs
Other Team Links
Other Sports Links
Non-Sports Links
Video Direct

Looking for great deals on MLB Baseball Tickets? Visit JustgreatTickets.com for Cubs Tickets, NY Mets Tickets and a huge selection of Red Sox Tickets, Yankees Tickets and plenty of great concert Tickets for Dave Matthews Band Tickets and Buffett Tickets

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by
Movable Type 4.1